• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)
  • We're having a little contest, running until the end of March. Please feel free to enter - see the thread in the "I Did That" section of the forum. Don't be shy, have a go!

2 book recommendations for 2025…

Tom

Been here for ages!
Site Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2013
Messages
5,958
Reaction score
5,866
Location
USA
For my Merry Christmas present for you this year I offer recommendations of two of the books I am reading. You can find them yourself, I use Libby.

“Polka Heartland, Why the Midwest Loves to Polka” by Dick Blau and Rick March. Yeah, pretty clear what this book is about. By the way, Polka is still alive in Wisconsin from where me and the authors hail. This book covers the history, the culture, the people and venues here in beautiful cheesehead land. It’s text and lots of pictures. By the way, polkas here are played by “Dutchmen”, not because they are from the Netherlands, although some of the backwoods taverns might be. It’s a cultural experience, let’s leave it at that. I’m about the only Polka King left up here where you used to be able to run into one every time you tripped over a rock. Just sayin’

“Driftless” by David Rhodes takes place in “Schottische Heaven,” the “Driftless Area” of Wisconsin/Minnesota/Iowa. So called because there is no “Drift” here. Weird, huh? I’m not telling you what Drift is, you have to go read the book. Anyway, there are no accordions in the book, and more concertinas and squeezeboxes (what you call “melodeons”) than (piano) accordions anyway. Rolands and CBAs are seen as curious interlopers. The reason I bring this up is because amongst all the interesting characters in the interweaving stories is a cougar (the four legged variety which I have yet to see) and a mediocre (in her own mind) bass player trying to get by in the area dance bands, the musical connection. I didn’t tell you much of the story, but it’s well written and very telling of the culture of the Driftless. Plus I know you have google.

Anyway, Merry Christmas to you and please, tell us what books you got for us. Thanks!
 
“Music Lesson” by Victor Wooten
“Learn Faster, Perform Better” by Molly Gebrian
These two books improved my playing more than any method book I’ve used.
2 months ago, after almost two years of learning, I couldn’t play one song from memory, In 2 months I have 4 in my repertoire and 2 more almost ready. They have added excitement, enjoyment, purpose, and accomplishment to my practice sessions.
 
“Music Lesson” by Victor Wooten
“Learn Faster, Perform Better” by Molly Gebrian
These two books improved my playing more than any method book I’ve used.
2 months ago, after almost two years of learning, I couldn’t play one song from memory, In 2 months I have 4 in my repertoire and 2 more almost ready. They have added excitement, enjoyment, purpose, and accomplishment to my practice sessions.
Thanks Jeff! I love “Music Lesson”! I see Molly Gabrian’s book is only available (to me) on Kindle, seems like it would be worth it to buy. Good for you on the repertoire! Playing by memory, and learning by ear seem to be two skills that separate the pros from the aspirants.

Lately I have tunes running in my head all the time. New tunes, that I have never heard before, maybe based on tunes I know, maybe not all that “good.” Now, how to get them on the accordion is the thing. I think I understand a little of what Frankie went through. What if you could just play these tunes as a complete song at the gig? Without having to memorize all of someone else’s tunes? Wouldn’t that be something?
 
Me neither... I'll let you how I get on....but I do love that Wootenesque approach....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tom
Now here’s a picture you don’t usually see. Recognize these guys? (Not my picture, will be deleted.)

It was Lawrence Welk playing the accordion.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Jeff! I love “Music Lesson”! I see Molly Gabrian’s book is only available (to me) on Kindle, seems like it would be worth it to buy. Good for you on the repertoire! Playing by memory, and learning by ear seem to be two skills that separate the pros from the aspirants.

Lately I have tunes running in my head all the time. New tunes, that I have never heard before, maybe based on tunes I know, maybe not all that “good.” Now, how to get them on the accordion is the thing. I think I understand a little of what Frankie went through. What if you could just play these tunes as a complete song at the gig? Without having to memorize all of someone else’s tunes? Wouldn’t that be something?
Molly Gebrian's book available in paperback:

Howard
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tom
“Driftless” by David Rhodes takes place in “Schottische Heaven,” the “Driftless Area” of Wisconsin/Minnesota/Iowa. So called because there is no “Drift” here. Weird, huh? I’m not telling you what Drift is, you have to go read the book.
Here you are:🙂
 
Recognize these guys?
Some more about Rudy Burkhalter🙂:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tom
Did anyone recognize our old friend Lawrence W playing that giant accordion?
 
Did anyone recognize our old friend Lawrence W playing that giant accordion?
Nope, not until you mentioned it... and Welk only played PA... lol

There is a smaller version at the accordion museum and a larger version at the Hohner museum in Trossingen. :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tom
“Music Lesson” by Victor Wooten
“Learn Faster, Perform Better” by Molly Gebrian

The Gebrian is new to me. I tracked down the ebook this morning and it looks interesting. I got a lot out of a couple similar books a couple years ago (one was Klickstein's The Musician's Way and the other, as the old joke goes, wasn't. Wish I could remember because I ought to read it again; practice time this year has been a lot less productive than last year.)

I read the Wooten just a few months ago as a result of a flood of similar recommendations on another forum. I seem to be the only one who (to put it politely) doesn't speak the same language he does.
 
Now that’s interesting. I always thought Frankie Yankovic wrote “Just Because,” but it seems his was a cover version in polka style. Just goes to show you!
 
“Flaco Jimenez, a Grammy-winning, Norteño-style musician from Texas who later played with Bob Dylan, Ry Cooder, and the Rolling Stones, in a promotional photo taken in the 1980s.”

See, this right here tells you all you need to know about the accordion in America in the early 2000s.

Why not:

“Bob Dylan, Ry Cooder, and the Rolling Stones all played with Flaco Jimenez, a Grammy-winning, Norteño-style musician from Texas, in a promotional photo taken in the 1980s.”

We get no respect!
 
Back
Top