• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)

Neuroscience and psychology of accordion playing

Gatorcheesehead

Member
Site Supporter
Joined
Feb 26, 2023
Messages
69
Reaction score
64
Location
Wisconsin
Has anyone studied or found resources, books, reputable articles about the neuroscience and psychology that is applicable to learning and playing the accordion?
I am taking an anatomy class for a different pursuit and yet found myself wondering about it when we were studying the brain.

What of these (I haven't yet read them)?


 
Daniel Levitin's This is Your Brain on Music is definitely worth a read.

I also really like Daniel Coyle's The Talent Code, which, among other things, gets into the role of myelination in learning. And of course, there's Carol Dweck's Mindset (more on the psychological than physiological end of things). Neither of those two are specifically about music, but they do apply in general.
 
If I don't play in a day I get depressed. Other than that I suppose it's good for you. On another note I have been known to sketch many accordions and players, and to make accordion ai art. My sketches aren't good enough to post. Maybe later. Cooking maple syrup today, probably play my Lira around the fire. I'm a real cheesehead don'tcha know.
 
What of these (I haven't yet read them)?
I am very sorry, but this journal does not seem to be a reliable scientific source. Web of Science de-listed 82 journals, including 15 from Hindawi (among them also this scientific journal). Contemporary "scientists" use all possible and impossible ways to achieve publication activity. the result is often confusing studies with little (or no) informative value, or even misleading information. This kind of publicity is then rather harmful to the accordion. Please read everything with distance, reserve and impartiality, even if they write about our beloved musical instrument.

Best regards, Vladimir
 
If I don't play in a day I get depressed. Other than that I suppose it's good for you. On another note I have been known to sketch many accordions and players, and to make accordion ai art. My sketches aren't good enough to post. Maybe later. Cooking maple syrup today, probably play my Lira around the fire. I'm a real cheesehead don'tcha know.
Many years ago, before the advent of the EEC, you used to get about 1000 liras to the dollar.
They must have increased in value a bit since then. Or am I thinking of something else? :unsure: :)
 
You might want to check back issues of the Modern Accordion Perspectives journal. Their website seems to be dead, but the facebook page is still live, and I see one of the issues are available for download.

It's the most "high-brow" accordion publication I know of, so the closest that's been to somebody who'd have discussed the accordion specifically like that probably.

In issue #3, Elzbieta Rosinska of the Gdansk Academy Of Music asks a series of questions and mentions "neuroscience" in her article, The development of the Polish educational accordion repertoire in 1970-2000.

At least temporarily I've put a link to my downloaded copy of that issue here:

(Question, followed by Respondants, and their answers of that article. Not the most deep content for what you want. Most of the contents of these journals are about conservatory-level pedagogy and composition and such, not the science behind the instrument itself.

In the past, graduated accordion students become professional educators without a specific pedagogic training. The knowledge of elements of psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body-mind awareness is an essential tool for teaching young children? What are the basic skills that a teacher have to master to be a good music educator?


Guillaume Hodeau:

- Human body and different techniques (Alexander Technique...)
- Great skills on the instrument
- Know the repertoire (always keep up to date), performers, schools, teachers
- Be curious of everything
- Study the human development (especially 5 to 20 years-old)
- Be very demanding with your students but at the same time kind and reassuring - Read all studies about brain development and music


Marko Kassl: Well - actually personally I think that of course all those elements listed in the question are very important. On the other hand there are a couple of things that no accordion student can learn in the study! Ones personal approach and contact to young children is crucial for transporting all that know-how. So if a teacher has all the knowledge in the world but can't reach and touch the child where it is he will not be able to transport that knowledge! So one of the most basic skills in my opinion is to know what Your "teaching character" is and to use it in the right way - this knowledge one gets only by teaching and trying - learning by doing.


Patrick Busseuil: This is a very difficult question, experience shows me that there is no rule, we encounter very graduated people with poor education and also opposite! Of course, the teacher who has taken courses in several areas more likely to be a good teacher. It is first necessary that the teacher thinks he has continued to be a student for life!


Raimo Vertainen: As wide as possible; psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body.Well... is one life long enough for this?


Viatcheslav Semionov: The musical learning of a child should be conscious from the very beginning, that is, the student should understand the tasks, and the teacher should guide and help to solve them, unlike the average training methods (exercise, repeat without understanding what you are doing) that makes learning process kind of sports training. In this way nobody will be interested in these trained students in the future because they have nothing to say, due to the fact that they don’t have spiritual advance and intellectual development.
 
You might want to check back issues of the Modern Accordion Perspectives journal. Their website seems to be dead, but the facebook page is still live, and I see one of the issues are available for download.

It's the most "high-brow" accordion publication I know of, so the closest that's been to somebody who'd have discussed the accordion specifically like that probably.

In issue #3, Elzbieta Rosinska of the Gdansk Academy Of Music asks a series of questions and mentions "neuroscience" in her article, The development of the Polish educational accordion repertoire in 1970-2000.

At least temporarily I've put a link to my downloaded copy of that issue here:

(Question, followed by Respondants, and their answers of that article. Not the most deep content for what you want. Most of the contents of these journals are about conservatory-level pedagogy and composition and such, not the science behind the instrument itself.

In the past, graduated accordion students become professional educators without a specific pedagogic training. The knowledge of elements of psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body-mind awareness is an essential tool for teaching young children? What are the basic skills that a teacher have to master to be a good music educator?


Guillaume Hodeau:

- Human body and different techniques (Alexander Technique...)
- Great skills on the instrument
- Know the repertoire (always keep up to date), performers, schools, teachers
- Be curious of everything
- Study the human development (especially 5 to 20 years-old)
- Be very demanding with your students but at the same time kind and reassuring - Read all studies about brain development and music


Marko Kassl: Well - actually personally I think that of course all those elements listed in the question are very important. On the other hand there are a couple of things that no accordion student can learn in the study! Ones personal approach and contact to young children is crucial for transporting all that know-how. So if a teacher has all the knowledge in the world but can't reach and touch the child where it is he will not be able to transport that knowledge! So one of the most basic skills in my opinion is to know what Your "teaching character" is and to use it in the right way - this knowledge one gets only by teaching and trying - learning by doing.


Patrick Busseuil: This is a very difficult question, experience shows me that there is no rule, we encounter very graduated people with poor education and also opposite! Of course, the teacher who has taken courses in several areas more likely to be a good teacher. It is first necessary that the teacher thinks he has continued to be a student for life!


Raimo Vertainen: As wide as possible; psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body.Well... is one life long enough for this?


Viatcheslav Semionov: The musical learning of a child should be conscious from the very beginning, that is, the student should understand the tasks, and the teacher should guide and help to solve them, unlike the average training methods (exercise, repeat without understanding what you are doing) that makes learning process kind of sports training. In this way nobody will be interested in these trained students in the future because they have nothing to say, due to the fact that they don’t have spiritual advance and intellectual development.
Thanks Up, very interesting! The part about "having something to say" seems key here. Seems to me teaching "how to play" is of course necessary, but only a first step. Teaching expression, individual approach, musicality is more obscure, but seems to be more in vogue these days which is a good thing. For example, I'm teaching my friend how to play bass guitar right now (self serving 🤣, trying to get a new band going). He started by downloading and working out (intricate) tabs to songs he likes. I'm like "No! Here's the pattern for 1,3,5, you decide what to play, 2 measures of C, 2 measures of G, here we go, 1,2,3,4...."

The whole performance pedagogy directed towards winning the coupe mondiale is fascinating but not my cup of tea. Including musicality in those super difficult pieces is way more difficult, imho. More power to 'em, I say, but give me the songs my feeble mind can relate to!
 
Has anyone studied or found resources, books, reputable articles about the neuroscience and psychology that is applicable to learning and playing the accordion?
I am taking an anatomy class for a different pursuit and yet found myself wondering about it when we were studying the brain.

What of these (I haven't yet read them)?


I have done more research on the trumpet side of psychological aspects of music. "The Inner Game of Music" is pretty solid in relation to psychology of music performance aspects. It takes some deciphering, but books on pedagogy focus on psychology a little bit whether they intend to or not.

The Levithan book is good for sure too!

For specific accordion content you might be able to look for music therapy applications, I understand that the accordion is somewhat important in those aspects, but you might want to fact check that. :)
 
I have done more research on the trumpet side of psychological aspects of music. "The Inner Game of Music" is pretty solid in relation to psychology of music performance aspects. It takes some deciphering, but books on pedagogy focus on psychology a little bit whether they intend to or not.

The Levithan book is good for sure too!

For specific accordion content you might be able to look for music therapy applications, I understand that the accordion is somewhat important in those aspects, but you might want to fact check that. :)
Thank you! I read the sample of the inner game. I definitely going to check out the rest of the book
 
You might want to check back issues of the Modern Accordion Perspectives journal. Their website seems to be dead, but the facebook page is still live, and I see one of the issues are available for download.

It's the most "high-brow" accordion publication I know of, so the closest that's been to somebody who'd have discussed the accordion specifically like that probably.

In issue #3, Elzbieta Rosinska of the Gdansk Academy Of Music asks a series of questions and mentions "neuroscience" in her article, The development of the Polish educational accordion repertoire in 1970-2000.

At least temporarily I've put a link to my downloaded copy of that issue here:

(Question, followed by Respondants, and their answers of that article. Not the most deep content for what you want. Most of the contents of these journals are about conservatory-level pedagogy and composition and such, not the science behind the instrument itself.

In the past, graduated accordion students become professional educators without a specific pedagogic training. The knowledge of elements of psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body-mind awareness is an essential tool for teaching young children? What are the basic skills that a teacher have to master to be a good music educator?


Guillaume Hodeau:

- Human body and different techniques (Alexander Technique...)
- Great skills on the instrument
- Know the repertoire (always keep up to date), performers, schools, teachers
- Be curious of everything
- Study the human development (especially 5 to 20 years-old)
- Be very demanding with your students but at the same time kind and reassuring - Read all studies about brain development and music


Marko Kassl: Well - actually personally I think that of course all those elements listed in the question are very important. On the other hand there are a couple of things that no accordion student can learn in the study! Ones personal approach and contact to young children is crucial for transporting all that know-how. So if a teacher has all the knowledge in the world but can't reach and touch the child where it is he will not be able to transport that knowledge! So one of the most basic skills in my opinion is to know what Your "teaching character" is and to use it in the right way - this knowledge one gets only by teaching and trying - learning by doing.


Patrick Busseuil: This is a very difficult question, experience shows me that there is no rule, we encounter very graduated people with poor education and also opposite! Of course, the teacher who has taken courses in several areas more likely to be a good teacher. It is first necessary that the teacher thinks he has continued to be a student for life!


Raimo Vertainen: As wide as possible; psychology, cognitive neuroscience, sociology, aesthetics, body.Well... is one life long enough for this?


Viatcheslav Semionov: The musical learning of a child should be conscious from the very beginning, that is, the student should understand the tasks, and the teacher should guide and help to solve them, unlike the average training methods (exercise, repeat without understanding what you are doing) that makes learning process kind of sports training. In this way nobody will be interested in these trained students in the future because they have nothing to say, due to the fact that they don’t have spiritual advance and intellectual development.
Brilliant! Thank you for this resource. I'm not sure if it is still going, though their previous publications seem quite intriguing.
 
Daniel Levitin's This is Your Brain on Music is definitely worth a read.

I also really like Daniel Coyle's The Talent Code, which, among other things, gets into the role of myelination in learning. And of course, there's Carol Dweck's Mindset (more on the psychological than physiological end of things). Neither of those two are specifically about music, but they do apply in general.
I have added Levitin's works to my reading list. Thank you! There is a growing movement on raising the awareness and benefits of myelination. I honestly had no idea even what myelin was until a few weeks ago when a basic anatomy class I am taking brought it up. Very interesting. But again, thank you for the recommendations for the The Talent Code and Mindset. I have another long road trip coming up and might see if I can find them on audio book for some nice listening while appreciating the great plains scenery
 
While again, not accordion specific and maybe not super mind blowing or deep...they seem applicable and interesting:





 
Back
Top