• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)

Primer on old and new accordion Microphones

Ventura

Been here for ages!
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
2,426
Reaction score
3,075
Location
mid-atlantic, USA
maybe a quick primer is in order

Micophone technology has advanced a huge amount since the early days of
am[plified Accordion

so the first thing to realise, if you want to amplify an older accordion well,
to a professional, useful level of quality, remove and replace the old Mics
with a modern system

if you just want to amp it occasionally for fun, it is possible to re-furb
the older style factory Mics by replacing ALL the Wiring with new shielded cable.

you may find 3 types of Mic elements in an old accordion, none of these
older elements require a Bias voltage or phantom power. The oldest is
a Carbon element Mic, next is (Salt) Crystal elements, and the more modern
is the Moving Coil/Magnetic/DYNAMIC mic element

carbon and crystal Mics excite the base material through a diaphram which creates a signal

widely used, crystal elements have very poor low frequency response, and wild high
freqency harmonics and peaks which contribute to runaway Feedback, and are
very difficult to EQ or otherwise control to an actual useful volume level. additionally,
Moisture and heat evaporate some crystals, while others have simply desintegrated
from shock vibration while traveling in the case. Peeling back the aluminum
body of a Cryatal Mic often reveals the positive and negative leads connected to air.

Dynamic elements can be identified as the round Magnet assembly is often visible
from the back.. like a tiny speaker, it just works in reverse with the moving coil
being energized by the permanent magnet and the motion generates the audio signal..
these are also noticeably heavier and a bit larger than crystal elements

Some dynamic elements found in accordions were very high quality and well made,
unfortunately they were often held in place with cork or early foam or compressed thick felts,
which have hardened with age

this is a problem because Mic elements need to be shielded from physical vibrations,
as they pick up those vibrations and amplify THEM too.. so the "signal to noise" ratio suffers.

think of a Mic stand that has lost it's rubber feet ages ago, sitting on a hollow raised
wooden Stage, and how every time someone takes a step you can hear it over the PA system.

older Mic systems in accordion were mostly simple wiring designs, with tone controls that
merely sink the higher frequencies to ground through a potentiometer, and no attempt
at equalizing the output from multiple elements side by side
(they just hoped they were relatively all more or less equal)

many older Mic systems summed the bass and treble mic's for a monophonic output

in pretty much ALL cases, 50 year old internal wiring has become brittle, everything
is cracked and desintigrating and usually leaves exposed copper wire which shorts out..
in many cases the flexing wire inside the bellows connecting the bass chamber to the
controls on the treble grill have simply broken. (copper wire has a finite stretch/flex point)

even simpler Mic systems just stick the Bass mic inside the bellows, with a monophonic output,
some combine a bellows belly mic with other mics under the grill, but these are out of
phase and work poorly

if your old accordion has decent quality Mic Dynamic elements, you can re-mount them
and re-wire them and shine up the connecting jacks and spray the volume controls with contact cleaner

modern Mic systems use Powered (Electret) mic elements. even the cheapest of these has a
better response pattern (typically flat 20 - 20,000 Hertz) than old accordion Mics.
The biggest difference in modern elements used in Accordion systems is the higher quality
electrets like the Sennheiser and Panasonic are highly directional, and so resistant to feedback,
as well as being crafted to accept higher sound pressure waves without distorting.

regarding directional, consider the little clip on Mic you see used on TV interviews,
and that come with most simple wireless kits.. or the type hidden in your phone or computer..
these OMNIDIRECTIONAL elements pick up from all directions fairly well and are decent for
recording and ZOOM meetings

but onstage, the guitarist and drummer have their own amps and mics, they don't need
(or want) the little cheapie mic you clipped on to your bellows strap to amp them up too.

so your mics are better off INSIDE the grill and accordion body, where they are somewhat
shielded from stage noise, and if they are higher quality feed-back resistant CARDIOD pattern
elements that is the best

not all modern systems offered for Accordion installation are equal.. one brand name
sets their elements into machined aluminum slugs that are often glued into place
under the grille.. very susceptible to vibration..

Kits are available for the do-it-yourselfers, and most quality accordion shops
will offer one or two models with installation.. if you are handy with a soldering iron
and can read a schematic, it is not that difficult to build your own if you can
source a few decent Electret elements from a parts supply house. Simple
op-amp circuits are freely available on the web for audio use with low-battery drain.

there are many other discussions on Mic systems available on the web and this forum
 
Last edited:
An important thing to mention is that the better (more directional) mics require that more mic capsules are installed under the grille in order to pick up the sound pretty evenly from lowest to highest notes. There is a very commonly used "Sennheiser system" used in Italy that uses just 3 mic capsules. That is definitely not enough for capturing the sound from all the notes evenly. Decent systems will use 5 or 6 capsules under the treble grille, and some systems designed more specifically for cassotto instruments come with 10 capsules.
On the bass side the sound "resonates" quite evenly inside the bass compartiment (the holds the bass mechanism) so a single capsule can capture all the bass notes quite well. (And in fact, I'm not sure that using two capsules that are sometimes offered do a better job.) Placement is somewhat critical as you want to capture the musical sound and not the noises from the bass mechanism.
 
yes, thank you..

personally, having used many of the original Sennheiser systems,
i always installed/re-wired the 4th "Bass" mic in on the treble side, and
just used a big ol' Dynamic (like the Silver Bullet element) in the Bass chamber

and since i was just wanting a fat, deep Bass sound, would just sink
the higher frequencies to Ground with a pre-set tone control circuit
(which also eliminates most mechanism noises)
but i suppose the Free Bass people and the Orchestral Music folks
would like the left side to be full frequency so as to blend nicely
when extending the treble side music/chords/etc.

i have noticed and looked at the specs on some of the newer Mic systems/kits,
and a few are compelling and likely are a nice improvement over the original
Sennheiser kits, though not a quantum leap in Quality as the electret
was over the Crystal and Dynamic setups of the past

for the "do it myself" stuff off the workbench, a 12 element panasonic monster
was my most ambitious accordion mic project ever attempted, though i had, as
a youth, once wired a dozen Radio Shack electrets together and stuffed them
into an old ASTATIC art deco tabletop Mic that had a dissapeared Rochelle Salt crystal..
i actually used it as my Vocal Mic in my High School Rock Band days

hey, it worked ! it was affordable ! it had incredible feedback !
 
May 2, 2016:
I was doing a bit of research in to mics around the time I found the mic system on my Morino died. I looked at factory replacement (not made anymore), I looked at a company that made nice high-end mics (http://www.pigini.homepage.t-online.de/Akkordeonmikro.htm << link no longer works), they wanted 750 EUROS to do a 10+3 setup and a more expensive 10+8 system at over 1000 Euros. Sorry, not happening.

May 17, 2016:
I did some more research and decided on a medium quality mono internal mic replacing the factory units along with an external pre-amp and was happy with the sound, but it was nowhere near "high quality"... lol Total investment? $40 for the preamp and $10 for the microphone capsule that I had sitting around doing nothing already.

October 21, 2016:
I decided to learn what it took to make my own electret setup and found that the theory was VERY basic (The 6 things needed are a 9-volt battery, an electret mic, a capacitor, a resistor, an IC board that holds the hardware and an amplification board!), and at the time priced out some DIY components for a 20+10 (20 on the treble side, 10 on the bass side) would cost *under* $100CDN using a popular Asian website for the parts, and then JimD mentioned the following:

"Now if your accordion output jack is wired to accept phantom power you can eliminate the battery and plug into a mixer or amp with phantom power"

I really liked that idea since 99% of the time that I record audio it is to a mixer that has good quality pre-amps AND offers the ability to give me solid phantom power output as well as moving the volume and tone controls out of the accordion and in to the mixer side... genius, no extra holes in the accordion!!

A setup like this would still be the 20+10 mic setup and if I had any brains, would cost about $150-$175 Canadian due to the fact that now I needed to integrate a power down circuit from 24 volts to 9 volts, need 2 PCB boards to transport the left and right hand signals out and design a bit more complex system.

My big issue? I was not that level of smart and relegated it to the "let's do this sometime in the future" bin. I do not know how to read schematics very well (I can, but only in the most basic manner), but I am not stupid and know that I could learn easily enough... but back then, as in now, my time is SO LIMITED that I really prefer to spend the little that I have in learning/playing than educating myself about electronics... but in the future, once I can stop working either most or all of the time, this is going to happen... *or* I may just get a little free help from someone that is interested in schooling me for a few hours... this stuff is definitely NOT rocket science. :)

I've since NOT advanced any further than this, but it really makes me wonder WHY these people are so greedy to charge upwards of $1000US for these setups when they are:
A - not as advanced as the 20+10 mic setup that would give best results for a FREE BASS instrument (which is always the goal!)
B - have no extra costs for internal tone and volume controls of the left and right sides (now that it is moved to the mixer!)

Only answer was "CASH GRAB". Yeah, not very enticing to me.

So, anyone want to collaborate on busting the accordion microphone scene and make the world's first and best UBER CHEAP setup that runs off of the mixer's phantom power? :)
 
Last edited:
well, if it is your mixer and the one you always use, you
could just change the output voltage there at the mixer
for the accordion channel with a bit of customizing
(more room over there likely)
might even find a $10 step-down buck module on Amazon
 
I have a microvox setup, and like it.

However, the downside of it is that it's battery powered. The electret mics need a few volts, Phantom power is up to 48V.

I replaced my Microvox power supply with a phantom power unit from Orchid Electronics. Like everything I've bought from Orchid, it's great quality, well engineered. Inputs from the treble and bass microvox mics, simple level control, and takes phantom power from the mixer.

I don't see it linked from the main Orchid page, but it's still there:
 
@JIM D. is a major proponent of the old mics. Perhaps he could share his point of view?
 
well it was physically quite difficult to make a truly high quality
magnetic/Dynamic capsule back then,, you have to keep the
Mic as flat as possible for an Accordion, so that really limits
the excursion of the diaphram and as a result it needs to be
perfect and efficiently convert the motion to electrical energy,
plus you have to justify spending extra on really small but powerful
magnets that can also be shaped as a thin, lightweight pancake

sohow smoothly can you wind a very very thin copper wire,
how tightly can you keep it wound.. how many can you make and
sell after you tooled up for your chosen "best" model ?

SHURE was the absolute best back then in the USA maybe the world, after
them the best Coil winders were probably working at Fender and Gibson

as i said, there were SOME really good ones.. but in the "few" category..

the Rochelle salt elements are not even worth salvaging, just think back
to when your little record player had a cheap crystal cartridge and then
Moving Magnet cartridges suddenly came out and overnight took
over the market in every wannabe serious turntable on the market

i still have a stock of old ASTATIC crystal 78 needle style cartridges for the Radio
Record players of the 1930's, but i havn't rebuilt one for awhile now.. crystal
cartridges WERE a slight improvement over the direct horn vibration amplifying
Wooden and Metal Horns of the wind-up Victrola era
 
Just this week I was looking for a Microvox setup, but I've been told they're out of business. Are there any low-cost alternatives? Longer term I'd like a Musictech internal system, but that's quite expensive compared to what my accordion cost.
 
Last edited:
oh it might be.. i was just trying to post up url's to make things
easier to find.. y'all feel free to add any other Accordion Mic
manufacturers sites you find

i couldn't find a Primary Microvox "factory" site, but this MrMicrophone page seemed
pretty good
 
Back
Top