Dingo40 said:
Maugein,
Well, as usual, your post was instructive and entertaining, as are the clips that illustrate it: all good, thanks!
It seems everywhere in life, if there’s more than one way of doing something, someone will always pick the other way of doing it!
It also explains why, on so many of my old vinyl accordion records, there is no accordion bass in evidence. I used to wonder about this, but this explains it.
Here in the UK one or two Scottish players were famous for economy of bellows movement, but playing the basses is almost mandatory, even if nobody can hear them.
A lot of French players won't buy Cavagnolo accordions, as the bass side on all 5 voices is usually a lot louder than the loudest treble combination, even if it's three voice musette. Probably a throwback to when you couldn't play an accordion unless there were dancers, but I just don't know.
There is an ambidextrous Norwegian guy, Øivind Farmen, who has the outside two rows on the bass side stepped so that he can get his thumb onto the bass buttons on those rows. His party piece is playing left and right hand melodies simultaneously on both sides with his converter box.
One of the things that attracted me to the accordion was what appeared to be its relative simplicity. I soon learned I'd got that one wrong, but if I had been Italian I might have been OK.
If you look at guitar tuition videos relative to the left hand, most teachers recognise that hardly any two people will have the same morphology. People with big hands can often just about get by without much use of the little finger, whereas some of us with small hands and short fingers struggle, and need to use our little fingers a lot. Consequently, the choice of left hand fingering is left up to the player. As long as the correct notes are played/sounded then there is no big deal.
Classical playing is something I've only ever experienced on trumpet, where there isn't much scope for deviation, but even so I seem to remember being shown some "alternative" valve combinations that weren't in the textbooks.
As you say, if there is an alternative way then some people will fly in the face of convention, and either be praised or more likely criticised for it. The accordion seems to have more scope for doing things wrong than any other musical instrument I know of. Before I became a member on here I had absolutely no idea how popular the accordion was in classical music. I have enough trouble playing tunes with three chords never mind the classics. Here in the UK the accordion wasn't even recognised as a "proper" musical instrument until about 1984, and that's why I stuck with the paper and comb for so long. After I realised the accordion was in fact a musical instrument I made the switch, as I kept getting into trouble with my teacher for bringing combs with teeth missing, and that knocked the tuning out!
I was never meant to be a musician, so I'm currently working on an alternative way to become a millionaire, as everything I've read in all the best books just hasn't worked for me.