• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)
  • We're having a little contest, running until the end of March. Please feel free to enter - see the thread in the "I Did That" section of the forum. Don't be shy, have a go!

On requests to teach accordion repair

Big Squeezy Accordions

Well-known member
Site Supporter
Joined
Nov 3, 2021
Messages
283
Reaction score
384
Location
New Orleans, USA
It seems that, lately, I have been getting a lot of requests, mostly from young people, to teach them accordion repair. Some live in my town, others are planning a visit for an extended period. I've always tried to be generous with the knowledge I've spent years gaining, and frequently show clients how to do small repairs themselves, rather than paying me to do them. I also spend several hours per week replying to people's accordion queries by email, again at no charge. I figure it's all part of maintaining a reputation for helpfulness and integrity. However, I am unsure how to deal with these increasing requests to teach accordion repair, for which no compensation is typically offered. It would be very strange to ask an auto mechanic to teach you how to fix cars, rather than paying them to do it for you, yet people think nothing of asking this of an accordion mechanic, apparently. I'm not interested in and don't have the physical space to hire an employee or apprentice. I have offered to work on someone's accordion with them, explaining what I am doing and letting them help, while charging my usual hourly rate, after which I don't tend to hear from them again. On one hand, I recognize a dearth of capable accordion technicians, and I'd like to be part of passing on these skills. Others were deeply generous with teaching me, and I'd like to pay that back. On the other hand, it all feels a bit entitled. I would never think of asking someone to give me something of real value without offering anything in return, and I wouldn't dream of plying this trade in the same region as the men who taught me, at least while they are still active. I am curious to know how other accordion techs handle these requests.
 
It seems that, lately, I have been getting a lot of requests, mostly from young people, to teach them accordion repair.
Though not an accordion technician myself, I think your offer to let them watch you doing it (with commentary) at your usual fee is most generous and possibly the best option all round!🙂
 
That’s a refreshingly generous approach. It seems to me that I read somewhere that the old master technicians were often reluctant to reveal their secrets. I follow the accordion repair group on Facebook, not because I want to learn to do it myself, but because it further helps me how accordions are constructed, how technicians compensate for bad design, and how to recognize when my acoustic accordion can use professional help.
 
If they live nearby I wouldn't be surprised if they are looking for an apprenticeship - which is how it would have been done 50 years ago, but now you can probably count the USA shops that have enough work to take on an apprentice on the fingers of one hand.

If their own accordion needs serviced anyway they may well take you up on your offer, but there's only so much they can learn from one session. It comes down to "what would you charge them, if anything, to watch you repair someone else's accordion?" - and that is a question of how close you are to wanting to do a mini-apprenticeship.

Between the lack of apprenticeships (paid or unpaid), and the cost of private lessons -- you've pinned down why people decide that flying to Italy for 2 weeks of group lessons is good value for money.
 
It seems that, lately, I have been getting a lot of requests, mostly from young people, to teach them accordion repair. ...
Send them to the Accordion Craft Academy in Castelfidardo (hosted by Victoria). They can learn the ropes from actual accordion makers and repairers, and in passing also learn that learning the trade does not come for free! (These courses are not cheap, and you should also add the expense of travel and lodging, but I found it a very valuable experience.)
 
Perhaps suggest that they contact World of Accordions in Wisconsin if they want to attend repair classes or pursue an apprenticeship in the US.
 
Send them to read this site:


They can teach themselves how to do most of the repairs, as is not rocket science or modern engineering, although kind of tricky. That's what I did in order to fix my own accordions. Although, I do have the support of Master Jerry King and Tempotrend store if I ever have questions regarding accordion repair.

Master Jack Brantley, founder of Accordionology, taught himself everything he needed in order to do accordion repair, just to mention an example

Also, the places that Debra and Tom mentioned are also a good option, although, I think these young people might not be able to afford those courses, or travel expenses.
 
I’m reminded of the old song which I will paraphrase here:

Don’t let your babies grow up to be accordion repairers.
Make them be electricians, plumbers and things,
Cause they’re never at home,
And there always alone,
Explaining that tipo a mano….
 
It seems that, lately, I have been getting a lot of requests, mostly from young people, to teach them accordion repair. Some live in my town, others are planning a visit for an extended period. I've always tried to be generous with the knowledge I've spent years gaining, and frequently show clients how to do small repairs themselves, rather than paying me to do them. I also spend several hours per week replying to people's accordion queries by email, again at no charge. I figure it's all part of maintaining a reputation for helpfulness and integrity. However, I am unsure how to deal with these increasing requests to teach accordion repair, for which no compensation is typically offered. It would be very strange to ask an auto mechanic to teach you how to fix cars, rather than paying them to do it for you, yet people think nothing of asking this of an accordion mechanic, apparently. I'm not interested in and don't have the physical space to hire an employee or apprentice. I have offered to work on someone's accordion with them, explaining what I am doing and letting them help, while charging my usual hourly rate, after which I don't tend to hear from them again. On one hand, I recognize a dearth of capable accordion technicians, and I'd like to be part of passing on these skills. Others were deeply generous with teaching me, and I'd like to pay that back. On the other hand, it all feels a bit entitled. I would never think of asking someone to give me something of real value without offering anything in return, and I wouldn't dream of plying this trade in the same region as the men who taught me, at least while they are still active. I am curious to know how other accordion techs handle these requests.
That's a very interesting post. Im not a technician but do send some of those emails. Technicians have been very generous to me with their time, one here in the UK even sent me his full workshop notes to help me with my project, if he had asked me for some money I wouldn't have seen any issue in paying, and if I need to call in the cavalry on a project he will be my first port of call.

Maybe you could advertise this as a service with a clear price structure? Might at least stop the entitled emails!

If there was an accordion repair man near me I would definitely pay for some guidance.
 
...

If there was an accordion repair man near me I would definitely pay for some guidance.
There was an old accordion repairer near me who taught me a few basics to get me started. He was even willing to teach me everything he knew if I promised that I too would later find an apprentice to spread that knowledge further. It sounded like a generous offer, but I could not honestly promise what he asked for. So instead I took the courses in Castelfidardo, and have not regretted that one bit!
 
There was an old accordion repairer near me who taught me a few basics to get me started. He was even willing to teach me everything he knew if I promised that I too would later find an apprentice to spread that knowledge further. It sounded like a generous offer, but I could not honestly promise what he asked for. So instead I took the courses in Castelfidardo, and have not regretted that one bit!
Make me your apprentice! (joking)

I will share everything I learn with my local fans and children (once I have them).
 
The one time that I asked to watch an accordion being repaired so that I could get a feel for it, it was for my own accordion, and I paid full boat for the work and did not argue the price. I did end up learning how to repalce the inner and outer valves which was pretty cool and was tasked to try my hand at it.

Now... did I do it well? First time, I think I hit ONE out of TEN... nine had to be done a second time for slight misalignment issues. I did better moving forward.

I also did watch and learn a lot more... but the best lesson I learned was that it is sincerely time and skill intensive. Anyone can slap it together, but it takes a master to do it once and do it right. If I was considering doing repairs professionally, I would have no issues paying for the knowledge, even going to Italy for the schooling. As it is, if I do repairs, it will be for me on my own hardware and can accept the learning process and fun of just being able to do so.
 
Since reading through the comments on this thread I've decided to go over to Italy and do some training. It isn't too far from me and I think it looks like good value. If anyone has an instrument in Northern Europe with potential which needs a lot of work for sale please let me know!
 
Back
Top