• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)
  • We're having a little contest, running until the end of March. Please feel free to enter - see the thread in the "I Did That" section of the forum. Don't be shy, have a go!

Why not more famous?

JerryPH

Been here for ages!
Site Supporter
Joined
Feb 16, 2016
Messages
6,790
Reaction score
5,589
Location
Montreal, Quebec, Canada
When I was in Amsterdam, the gent that I picked up the Gola from and I talked and I was introduced to an amazing accordionist... Harry Mooten. I am pretty sure not many if any, have heard this guy.

Amazing accordionist (played a Gola... LOL). The guy was comfortable playing Paganini as easily as Gershwin and 2 extra points in that he played on a Free Bass Gola!. :)





Why wasn't this guy better known?? As big as the world is, the internet has brought it all down to the size of a computer a screen... but not always. :)
 
Harry Mooten was world famous, especially (and maybe only) in the Netherlands.
He has many records including several with Bach. He recorded many works by Bach: two-part and three-part inventions, preludes and fugues, etc.
Sadly he was also a heavy smoker and drinker (he supposedly needed a few drinks from his flask before playing)...
The person who later bought Harry Mooten's Gola reported that he could never completely get the smell of smoke out of the accordion...
 
Harry Mooten ( Amsterdam , May 2 , 1928 – Amstelveen , December 13, 1996 ) was a Dutch accordionist . He was best known to the general public as musical accompanist and "big gray goat knitter" in De film van Ome Willem , with fellow musicians Harry Bannink and Frank Noya .

Harry_Mooten.png
Harry Mooten in 1959

Mooten was already active on the accordion as a child. Initially, Willy Alberti took him under his wing and played popular music. Later Mooten also played classical works by, for example, Bach . In 1972, Mooten received an Edison for his classical works.

1696190777798.png

I was so enthralled that I stayed a bit longer and we listened to 2 of his records, that's where I discovered the Paganini Perpetuum Mobile, a very long and complex piece... really entrancing.
 
Last edited:
Sadly he was also a heavy smoker and drinker..
The person who later bought Harry Mooten's Gola reported that he could never completely get the smell of smoke out of the accordion...
Like Johnny Meijer?πŸ€”
I have an old Busilacchio that stank of smoke for years: fresh as a daisy now!πŸ™‚
( The tobacco smoke did keep the moths out, though!!πŸ˜„)
 
Last edited:
Why wasn't this guy better known??
The answer lies here:πŸ€”
"I returned, and saw under the sun, that the race is not to the swift, nor the battle to the strong, neither yet bread to the wise, nor yet riches to men of understanding, nor yet favour to men of skill; but time and chance happeneth to them all."
Ecclesiastes 9.11
Here he is again:πŸ™‚
 
Last edited:
Johnny Meijer was a famous jazz accordion player. (He played button accordion.)
Harry Mooten played classical music and also light music (but is not known for jazz). He played for instance in TV programs made for children, where he accompanied songs and also played some background music. That made him famous in the Netherlands, but as these TV programs were all only in Dutch that fame did not carry very far. His fame that did reach far was with the baroque and classical music, showing what an accordion (with MIII) can do.
 
I am not sure why, because I don't usually dig deeper for info about musicians more than a peripheral/singular google search, but the more I dig, there are a few more hints around... like that he did 28 records/singles/albums and someone made a compilation of him and Johnny Meyer (13 songs, more folksy/traditional nothing classical).

He died quite young at 68... his obituary:

Last Friday, Dutch accordionist (and accordion pioneer) Harry Mooten
died. I've translated the obituary from today's Volkskrant below:
==========================
Harrie Mooten (68)
A musician that sought for recognition for the accordion
A working class boy from Amsterdam that created a festive atmosphere
at parties, but also a driven craftsman that won an Edison [a Dutch
Grammy] with his interpretations of Bach and other classical
composers. The musical life of accordionist Harry Mooten (age 68),
who died last Friday from a serious illness, was mainly devoted to
the recognition for his instrument.
Until long after the war, the squeezebox was viewed as a musical
instrument that could only be used to start a polonaise. By his
switch from entertainment to classical music, Mooten in the
sixties and seventies brought the accordion in vogue even at the
conservatory.
'I hope to be an example for people who also want to try to get
something refined out of their accordion', he said about that.
The self-taught man Harry Mooten won awards both for his popular
interpretations and for his classical renditions. In 1969 he
was awarded an Edison for his 'light' work, in 1972 for his records
with pieces by Bach and Beethoven. Apart from that, he made five
records with light jazz music.
Mootens talent came to light early. Already at the age of seven he
played banjo and appeared on VARA radio. At the age of nine he switched
to accordion. Shortly after, [Dutch popular singer] Willy Alberty paved
his way to a musical carreer by putting him in the spotlight during
concerts as 'the wonder boy on the squeezebox'.
Afterwards, Mooten played at various radio orchestras, and
effortlessly he switched to television. He became well known from his
appearances with Harry Bannink. In later years, with his ensemble
he accompanied Jasperina the Jong in the theatre.
All those years, he combined the serious work with gigs in the
commercial circuit. 'I am at home both at weddings and in the
Concertgebouw [Amsterdam's main classical concert hall]'.
In later years, Mooten found a new audience. For the youth,
he became known as 'de Grote Grijze Geitenbreier' [the Great Greay
Goat knitter], the musical right hand of Edwin Rutten in
the children's TV series 'de film van Ome Willem' [the movie of
Uncle William].
==========================


Two thoughts... That is the kind of man that should have found someone to mentor, to continue his legacy, perhaps taught a little at a conservatory. Kind of what Joe Macerollo is doing with Michael Bridge. I feel that no matter what the reason, illness, drinking, smoking, he passed too early and had so much to give. Also, wow, not bad for a self-taught man, that's the highest level I have personally seen anyone reach without "professional assistance".

This seems to be a repetitive story in many genres where talent, skill, ability and popularity lay strong in a person.
 
I had never heard of him. Couple of observations:

He looks like Captain Kangaroo in those initial couple of pictures.

I thought he was practicing on that first song. That's more a testament to my lack of classical knowledge, however.

The second song - wow - there's a definite Art Van Damme vibe there. Plays so fast that the notes almost slur and his ability to swing like Art is strong. First accordionist I've ever heard that sounds eerily similar to Art.

I do know Johnny Meijer's work. Brilliant jazz guy but apparently a beast to work with.
 
I thought he was practicing on that first song. That's more a testament to my lack of classical knowledge, however.

It is not just you, I think.

It is the fastest (by far), but the least clear, recording of the Paganini I have heard, on any instrument. The music just says "allegro vivace" and in many editions gives no further instructions - but some editions write "staccato e uguale" (separate and equal) under the solo part. Whether 'staccato' is written in the part or not, no violinist ever plays it legato, let alone slurred.
The goal is not playing it as fast as possible; it's an exercise in clarity and precision, articulating all the notes distinctly and in the same way, and maintaining whatever tempo you set, however slow or fast that may be.

Here is a representative example of a violinist for you to compare:

After sampling a half dozen youtubes of accordionists attempting it, I think Victor Wang's rises best to the "clarity and precision" challenge - making the notes the same length, and the same distance apart.
 
It is not just you, I think.

It is the fastest (by far), but the least clear, recording of the Paganini I have heard, on any instrument. The music just says "allegro vivace" and in many editions gives no further instructions - but some editions write "staccato e uguale" (separate and equal) under the solo part. Whether 'staccato' is written in the part or not, no violinist ever plays it legato, let alone slurred.
The goal is not playing it as fast as possible; it's an exercise in clarity and precision, articulating all the notes distinctly and in the same way, and maintaining whatever tempo you set, however slow or fast that may be.

...
That Paganini is indeed a bit sloppy. It is played very fast leggiero, which I think is the furthest away from legato you can get at this speed and still have all the notes really come out. You simply cannot play infinitely fast on an accordion because the mechanism, valves and reeds just cannot go any faster at some point.
I don't like the Gershwin recording any better, not because of how it's played (that's excellent) but because of the acoustics in the recording. The sound starts out rather dry and then at 0:30 in the recording when the combo starts playing the acoustics suddenly "open up". It's almost as if the intro is played behind a curtain that then opens at 0:30 and the room or concert hall acoustics kick in... We shouldn't forget that recording technique has evolved quite a bit in the past 50 years...
 
For those on the forum who are not Boomer/Gen-X Americans, this is what Captain Kangaroo looks like. Separated at birth, perhaps?

034205896d6f0a890c031d11e25df365b135b1bf.jpeg
 
When I was in Amsterdam, the gent that I picked up the Gola from and I talked and I was introduced to an amazing accordionist... Harry Mooten. I am pretty sure not many if any, have heard this guy.

Amazing accordionist (played a Gola... LOL). The guy was comfortable playing Paganini as easily as Gershwin and 2 extra points in that he played on a Free Bass Gola!. :)
I appreciate the introduction to Harry Mooten, a remarkable accordionist. I'm currently practicing a piece he recorded, Chopin's Prelude, Op. 28, No. 6. His performance on the accordion is unparalleled, the best I've encountered. Why isn't this piece more widely played on accordion? It suits the instrument so well. The free bass accordion has a plaintive quality that is quite different from all other instruments.

Here's Mr Mooten's rendition:​

 
Back
Top