• If you haven't done so already, please add a location to your profile. This helps when people are trying to assist you, suggest resources, etc. Thanks (Click the "X" to the top right of this message to disable it)

Will learning the piano improve my accordion skills?

That's one of the main problems in e-mail/internet communication, when you don't hear the voice and don't see the face, you can arrive at remarkable misinterpretations (generally speaking).
Its also the problem with the English and America- we have a level of irony that doesn't quite transplant across the ocean :)
 
Its also the problem with the English and America- we have a level of irony that doesn't quite transplant across the ocean :)
The irony transplants fine with enough exposure to British comedies. I’ve picked it up and so has my son. However, my countrymen sometimes can’t tell when I’m joking… I suppose a deadpan delivery works the same as text with no emojis.
 
My musical journey has been PA - piano - PA (but never both at the same time), and I would answer "no" to the question in the title, just from practical experience, with no elaborate theory behind it. Certainly it didn't work the other way around for me. That was my original thinking ("how hard can the piano be if I can already play the accordion"), and I was in for a surprise.
Of course, there are some skills (counting comes to mind) that are common to all instruments, so in that sense your practice time on the piano is not completely wasted even from the accordion's point of view, but that time would be much better spent practicing the accordion if that's your goal.
This question is always asked of me (because I play accordion) you should be able to play the piano too?
 
@saundersbp, Please may I ask, if an accordionist had the desire to take up the piano - what would you recommend as a good quality upright (house) piano brand/model?
Seems nobody wants an old standard piano where I live, so a free piano is what I would recommend. It costs to get rid of them and small businesses have been started dismantling them. There is no joke on how heavy they are to move though!
 
I play both an equal amount of time. My piano-playing skills are mediocre, mostly because of a pathetic left hand. I did play in a piano bar while in college for a couple years, basically faking it with simple chords on the left hand while the right hand was respectable. I abused the heck out of slash chords.

I've never found much difference in transitioning to accordions after playing piano. But then again, I've never noticed much difference transitioning from plastic Roland FR-8X keys to wooden acoustic keys either. I guess I've played all of them so much that I instinctively know how they play.

I'm pretty big into synths and tend to spend a lot of time duplicating Pet Shop Boys sounds and songs from my youth in the 80s. It's weird, for sure.

Just as I could never be without an accordion, I can't be without a synthesizer. My FR-8X has been in the shop since December 9th getting a new MIDI board. I cannot tell you how much I miss it. I have noticed I've played my acoustics about half the amount of time I normally play the accordion - and I've about doubled the amount of time I play the piano.
 
May a Fisa, will get in, if you can get a deal like you did on your 8X.
Hmmm... I really don't know if that will ever happen. I bought mine for less than half cost and it was still so new that it was on it's FIRST charge. Even then, $4000US is still about $6500 Canadian after duty and taxes. I'd have to think long and hard if I would want to do that.
Honestly, not likely even at that price, but your kind sentiments are sincerely appreciated! :)
 
Back
Top